R_4p1_1660

relation · concept: kārya-kāraņa · 2 attestation(s) · confidence 0.85

kārya-kāraṇa (effect-cause) relation between śruti and svara is rejected: cause perceptible while effects present contradicts the model

Body (pseudocode)

ASSERT NOT cause_effect(śruti, svara) RATIONALE: analogy(clay_lump, jar) — when jar exists, clay_lump is not perceptible; BUT śruti remains perceptible when svaras (kāryas) are present CONCLUDE no_pramāṇa for śruti existence under this model

Inputs / output

`śruti`	—
`svara`	—

→ epistemic_assertion

Evidence (2)

p. vol_I_p019 · #2199 « cause (śruti) is available when the kāryas (svaras) are present, (but)... the lump of clay is not available »
p. vol_I_p019 · #2201 « The relationship of cause and effect between śruti and svara is not possible »

R_4p1_1660

Body (pseudocode)

Inputs / output

Evidence (2)

Other rules in category relation

Other rules in category `relation`